Volume 4 Supplement 1
Effectiveness of pre-cooling and cooling during play on wheelchair rugby performance
© Griggs et al.; 2015
Published: 14 September 2015
Athletes with tetraplegia (spinal cord injury at the cervical region of the spinal cord) are at a greater risk of heat illness than their able-bodied counterparts, due to the loss of sweating capacity and vasomotor control below the lesion level. Commercially available ice vests worn prior to exercise (pre-cooling) have received considerable interest in the able-bodied athletic population eliciting varying results in performance, and physiological and thermoregulatory responses. However, limited research has been conducted in thermoregulatory impaired athletes with tetraplegia. Anecdotally water spraying the face and torso is commonly used by these athletes during breaks in play, though the effectiveness of this method has not been established. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of pre-cooling using an ice vest and the combination of pre-cooling and cooling during play using water sprays on simulated wheelchair rugby performance in athletes with tetraplegia.
Eight wheelchair rugby players with tetraplegia (32(7) yrs, 64.0(6.8) kg, 1.35(0.27) mL.kg.min-1) completed a 60 min intermittent sprint protocol (ISP) on a wheelchair ergometer in 20.2(0.2) °C and 33.0(3.1)% rh. The ISP represented a wheelchair rugby match (4 quarters) and was based on data obtained from competitive match play by an indoor tracking system. The ISP was conducted on three occasions either with no cooling (NC), pre-cooling with an ice vest (P) or pre-cooling with an ice vest and water sprays between quarters (PW). The ice vest (Artic Heat Products) weighed ~800g when activated, was worn over the top of the participant's playing vest and was applied during a 15 min rest period and subsequent 20 min warm-up. In PW, water (~ 17 °C) was sprayed twice (20 s spray) on the face, fronts of both arms and torso with a water spray (~50 mL per 20 s spray) at the end of each quarter. Gastrointestinal temperature was measured by a telemetry pill (Tgi), individual and mean skin temperature (Tsk, Ramanathan method), heart rate, rating of perceived exertion (RPE), thermal sensation and thermal comfort were measured throughout in addition to wheelchair performance.
At the end of the pre-cooling period, Tgi was 0.3(0.2) °C, 0.2(0.3) °C and 0.2(0.4) °C higher than at the start for NC, P and PW, respectively (p > 0.05). The reduction in Tsk over the pre-cooling period was significantly greater in P and PW compared to NC (-0.8(0.6) °C, -1.6(0.8) °C and -1.2(0.5) °C for NC, P and PW, respectively, p < 0.05). The ΔTgi over the ISP was significantly lower from the end of quarter 2 to completion of the ISP in PW and P compared to NC (p < 0.05). By the end of the second quarter to completion of the ISP, the reduction in Tsk was lower in PW compared to P and NC (p < 0.05). Cooling had no effect on heart rate, performance measures, RPE, thermal sensation or thermal comfort during the ISP.
Pre-cooling using an ice vest attenuated Tsk during the pre-cooling period, and although this reduction was not long lasting ΔTgi on completion of the ISP was still lower in P compared to NC. PW lowered thermal strain to a greater degree than P, yet neither condition had a detrimental effect on performance implying cooling did not affect the participant's pushing ability. Participants reported no differences in thermal sensation or comfort between conditions, suggesting they were unable to detect the attenuation in Tsk, potentially due to the small area of sensate skin in individuals with tetraplegia.
Water spraying between quarters in addition to pre-cooling with an ice vest lowers thermal strain to a greater degree than pre-cooling only, and has no detrimental effect on key parameters of wheelchair rugby performance or thermal perceptions.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.